Avy: 5/10 I like Kain, but it's a little bland
Sig: 9/10 Love the gif, it's small enough so it doesn't draw all attention away from the main body of the sig. The blue works really well and the image positioning is good.

Oh, JamesNintendoNerd. I like the game it's not all that bad and his enormous rant about the arching rocks was solved simply by crouching and throwing, plus you can get a knife within the first 15 seconds of the game and jump over most enemies anyways. But this is for a different thread altogether maybe I would present this statement at SA if I wasn't banned.

sig 7 / 10 - kind of plain, yet instantly recognizable and identifiable.

avy - 10 / 10 Odlaw is awesome, cant help but wonder too if hes not the inspiration for wario.

sig 7 / 10 - i like

avy - 9 / 10 - cause i was eating when i looked at it

She's unused/underrated, which if you know me by now is my mantra.

Sneez

Avatar: 6/10 - It's very common gif, but I've always enjoyed it. However, it's also just snagged from online. (Unless you happen to be the dude who made it You can consider this a 8/10 if that's the case)
Signature: 7/10 - The quality of it is nice, and I like the composition, but the image appears completely stretched ... I'm not sure if that's on purpose or not. It's not apparent just by looking at it.

Avatar: 9/10 Nice artsy fartsy pic
Signature: 10/10 Great Design

Avy: 9/10 I like Tsukasa's phone facial expressions
Sig: Console gifs are pretty coo' 7/10

Both Avy and Sig get an 8/10. Love the creepiness

BTW, the one in the spoiler is the one I really want rated. It's the first one that I've ever done professionally

EDIT: Also changed my avy (a photo I also took myself)

that haruhi sig... that left pig should've been on the right because of the cut on the right side. the images used were pretty clean. the font color is hard to read at first because it blends badly with the bg. nice first attempt tho.

6/10

avi gets a creepy 8/10


new sig...and month old avi rate em' please

Sig: 7/10. Sure love Voldemort.

Avatar: 7/10. Is that Iron Man? Anyway, he's pretty cute.

Nomad

Avy: 8/10. party time

Sig: 9/10. Don't know what to say about it except that I like it

AKADave

Avy: 8/10. I really like the simplicity of it, and the colours are easy on the eye.
Sig: 7/10. It's pretty good, but I'm not digging the fonts or the colour of the text. A more subtle red would be better. The scratched and grainy effect is awesome though, and those are some neat monsters.

Avatar: 8/10 Very artistic and colorful.
Sig: 9/10 Blue is my favorite color. Plus, the way it's made or whatever, looks good.

Sig: It's definitely personalized. 6/10
Avy: Shinobi rocks. 9/10

Overall: Builds a pretty well-rounded persona for your username. 8/10

Link

avatar- 8/10 Looks like Link finally snapped from hearing "LISTEN!"

Sig- 7/10 Plain imo, but its your thing.

To person after me-
I havent got around to make an avy or a sig I just grabbed one of my old drawings for avatar and just put something for sig. Dont judge too harshly